What to Do About the Mean Girls
If you have a daughter, take the time to read this. It could save her a lot of heartache. Not to mention stomach aches, headaches, missed days of school, lower grades, eating issues and depression.
The sad truth is that every school, whether public, private or parochial, has mean girls. I bet you can still even remember who they are from your school. As a school counselor and mother of three daughters, I know firsthand - both personally and professionally - how much it hurts when girls are targeted by bullies.
The old adage “sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me,” couldn’t be further from the truth. While boys usually bully through intimidation, girls bully through exclusion, also called relational aggression. Here's an example of a case of relational bullying, taken from my experience as a school counselor:
“Heather” was miserable because a girl in her class, “Leslie,” was not only saying mean things to her face, but getting the other girls in the class to exclude her with the age old line “You can’t be friends with me, if you’re friends with her.” In our sessions, Heather would complain that she didn’t have anyone to play with because girls were afraid that if they hung around her they’d become Leslie’s next target. Leslie had immense influence over the social dynamic among these girls.
In order to improve the situation, I had to not only reduce the power Leslie had, but empower Heather as well. Here are some ideas that helped, adapted for use by parents:
- Ask for specifics when your daughter hints at bullying. Who? Where? How?
- Tell the principal and classroom teacher the specifics of how she is being bullied. Have them tell other teachers (i.e., gym, art, music), recess aides, hallway monitors and cafeteria staff so that everyone who comes in contact with her can be on the lookout and poised to intervene.
- Explain to her that reporting an incident is not the same as tattling, and have her tell an adult at school when she is being bullied.
- Encourage her to stick with a friend at recess, lunch, in the hallways, on the bus or walking home because she is more likely to be targeted when she is alone.
- Teach her to convey self-confidence by walking confidently, with her head up. Bullies target those they think are weaker.
- Pay attention to how she is sleeping, eating, feeling and doing in school. If you notice changes in any of these areas, have her see the school counselor.
- Arrange opportunities for your daughter to socialize with her friends outside of school to help her maintain a strong social support system.
In Heather's case, these steps alleviated the problem. But because it’s tougher to catch girl bullies, it’s extremely important for girls to tell an adult if they are being bullied. Unlike boys, who usually bully physically, mean girls often spread rumors, whisper as their target walks by, talk loudly about a party she wasn’t invited to, give her the silent treatment, and as discussed above, tell others not to be friends with her. School personnel are there to help, but in order to do anything they must know a problem exists!
To read more about relational aggression, I recommend the following books:
- Odd Girl Out: The Hidden Culture of Aggression in Girls by Rachel Simmons
- Queen Bees and Wannabes: Helping Your Daughter Survive Cliques, Gossip, Boyfriends and Other Realities of Adolescence by Rosalind Wiseman
Take Action
- this article with friends and family.
- Have a question about Helping Your Child with Bullying? Ask it here.
- Publish your work on education.com.
Comments from readers
At this age (7) most kids pair off, and have no problem joining another group when one half of their pair is missing. My daughter has a couple of friends at school, but when the bully wants to play with these girls my daughter gets left out.
I have tried teaching her some approaches to (a) join in with another group/game with other kids and (b) what she can do when no one wants to play with her (I let her take one or two small toys to school that she can grab quickly when getting ready for recess), and tell her to make her own fun. However, there are more days that she comes home sad because no one wants to play with her, or let her join in.
What do you do when you have given your child coping techniques, and she is still being left out? How lonely it is to be excluded! It's a shame that three girls can be playing happily together, and then one joins the group and says "only three people are allowed to play, so you have to leave."
The best place to get your questions answered by other parents, teachers and experts on Education.com is our new tool, JustAsk, which you can access here:
http://www.education.com/answers/
Thank you!
I cannot remember how much pain I endured in elementary school, a place where you are supposed to be carefree and have a nice transition.
That wasn't my case.
Being the only Indian girl in my class, it was hard to deal with ridicule, but most people saw past that. I was friends with everyone, particularly with a girl at the time who I didn't know who was popular. M, K, Mel, and I were a tight-knit group of best friends, one could say. K and I were in every class together since kindergarten, and we had a great time. Then once 5th grade hit, K became very different. She made my life hell.
You see, M was the all around good girl. She was nice to everyone, and very popular. We were best friends, closer than the others. I suppose K did not see eye to eye with that because every time M was absent, K would terrorize me. She would make me look stupid for not knowing certain things, in front of other people nonetheless...and no one stopped it. Not even the teachers.
I particularly remember one day where she played the "I'm not friends with you" game when M was gone. Other girls didn't follow her suit as much, but I was so intimidated by K. She was a big part of my life before all of this. One of our other friends was taking pictures and wanted me to get in the picture...but K kept staring me down, so I declined.
Then when M returned, things were back to normal. Hugging. Laughing...it was so awful. I didn't realize until Middle School that it wasn't I who was doing things wrong. It was her.
That experience made my skin tougher, and I know better now, but having to deal with that at a young age isn't acceptable.
Your question has been added to JustAsk and you can review responses here:
http://www.education.com/question/child-excluded-cousin-lives-door/
Please use JustAsk for any future parenting or education questions you may have. Thank you!