THE PRESIDENT’S COUNCIL ON PHYSICAL FITNESS AND SPORTS (PCPFS) serves as a
catalyst to promote, encourage and motivate the development of physical
activity, fitness and sport participation for all Americans. This report
expresses the PCPFS’s mission to inform the general public of the
importance of developing and maintaining physical activity and fitness in
our daily lives, and to heighten awareness of the links that exist between
regular physical activity and good health. In the past, involvement in
sport and physical activity has been primarily associated with males. Over
the past two decades, however, girls’ and women’s involvement in such
activity has increased dramatically. This is in large part due to the
impact of Title IX, federal legislation passed in 1972 designed to prohibit
sex discrimination in educational settings. For example, prior to Title IX,
300,000 young women participated in interscholastic athletics nationwide;
today, that figure has leaped to approximately 2.25 million participants.
In the wake of this participation explosion, scholars and educators have
begun to explore its impact on girls and women.
Physical Activity and Sport in the Lives of Girls: Physical and Mental
Health Dimensions from an Interdisciplinary Approach was created in
order to highlight relevant research and draw on expert opinion regarding
girls’ involvement in physical activity and sport. This is the first report
that brings together research findings—and practical suggestions for
implementing these findings—from three interdisciplinary bodies of
knowledge: physiological, psychological and sociological.
The report focuses on girls and not boys (other than for comparison where
appropriate) for several reasons. First, with respect to sport and physical
activity, girls have been neglected by researchers in the biomedical
sciences, education, physical education and the social sciences. Second,
though girls and boys share common experiences, girls also exhibit unique
physiological, emotional and social outcomes that merit special
investigation. Next, scholars need to keep pace with the aforementioned
explosion and diversification of girls’ involvement with sport and physical
activity in the wake of Title IX. And finally, researchers increasingly
recognize that the social world of physical activity and sport is not a
one-dimensional universe, but a highly complex set of institutions
populated by two genders with diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds,
cultural values, physical abilities and sexual orientations.
Public apathy about physical education, and the glitzy distractions of
commercialized sports in mass media, sometimes hide the basic fact that
physical activity is a public health resource for millions of American
girls as well as their families and communities. In order to advance
knowledge regarding the real and potential contributions of physical
activity and sport in the lives of millions of girls, several areas for
future research are highlighted by the authors at the end of each section.
Finally, a set of policy recommendations is also included in order to
encourage responsible action on the part of parents, coaches, educators,
sport leaders and elected officials. With such a “teamwork” approach, we
can make a difference in the lives of girls.
KEY RESEARCH FINDINGS
Some of the most important research findings documented and highlighted in
this report suggest that:
- More girls are participating in a wider array of physical activities
and sports than ever before in American history.
(Introduction)
- Regular physical activity in adolescence can reduce girls’ risk for
obesity and hyperlipidemia (i.e., high levels of fat in the blood)which,
in turn, have been known to be associated with lower adult onset of
coronary heart disease and certain cancers. Regular physical activity can
also help girls build greater peak bone mass, thereby reducing adult risk
for osteoporosis. (Research Report, Section I)
- Exercise and sport participation can be used as a therapeutic and
preventative intervention for enhancing the physical and mental health of
adolescent females. (Research Report, Section IV)
- Exercise and sport participation can enhance mental health by offering
adolescent girls positive feelings about body image, improved
self-esteem, tangible experiences of competency and success and increased
self-confidence. (Research Report, Sections II and IV)
- Research suggests that physical activity is an effective tool for
reducing the symptoms of stress and depression among girls. (Research
Report, Sections II and IV)
- Sports are an educational asset in girls’ lives. Research findings show
that many high-school female athletes report higher grades and
standardized test scores and lower dropout rates, and are more likely to
go on to college than their nonathletic counterparts. (Research Report,
Section III)
- Recognition of physical activity and sport as an effective and
money-saving public health asset is growing among researchers and policy
makers. (Introduction; Research Report, Sections I, II and
IV)
- Poverty substantially limits many girls’ access to physical activity
and sport, especially girls of color who are overrepresented in lower
socioeconomic groups. (Introduction; Research Report, Section
III)
- Excessive exercise and certain forms of athletic participation have
been found to be associated with a higher prevalence of eating disorders.
(Research Report, Sections I, II, III and IV)
- The potential for some girls to derive positive experiences from
physical activity and sport is marred by lack of opportunity, gender
stereotypes and homophobia. (Research Report, Sections III and IV)
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
A summary of some of the most important conclusions and practical
recommendations discussed in this report suggest that:
- Girls should be encouraged to get involved in sport and physical
activity at an early age because such involvement reduces the likelihood
of developing a number of deleterious health-related conditions. For
example, active girls’ high caloric expenditure decreases their risk of
becoming obese. (Introduction; Research Report, Section
I)
- Specific mechanisms which enhance girls’ opportunities to be physically
active must be developed and supported. Recreational, school-based
physical education and sport programs are ideal ways to facilitate both
health-related fitness and the acquisition of fundamental motor skills
for a lifetime of activity. (Research Report, Section I)
- Involvement in sport and physical activity has tremendous potential to
enhance a girl’s sense of competence and control. Therefore, leaders
should incorporate cooperative as well as competitive opportunities to
learn physical skills in a nonthreatening environment. (Research Report,
Sections II and III)
- Parents, coaches and teachers must be aware of girls’ motives for
participating in sport and physical activity. Girls participate not only
for competitive reasons, but to get in shape, socialize, improve skills
and have fun. All motives, not just those related to highly competitive
activity, must be respected and validated. (Research Report, Sections II
and III)
- Physical educators, exercise leaders and coaches are in a primary
position to recognize disordered eating patterns among girls. These
individuals must be knowledgeable about the physical and psychological
signs and be able to make referrals to specialists as necessary.
(Research Report, Section II)
- Girls and boys need to work and play together, starting from an early
age. It is often easier for both sexes to play together and learn in
small, relaxed groups where children know each other well and have the
prerequisite skills. (Research Report, Section III)
- Coaches and physical educators should give girls equal access and
attention. Girls as well as boys should play the important and
interesting positions in a game and receive feedback to help improve
their physical skills. (Research Report, Section III)
- Professionals must actively intervene in the face of discrimination.
When adults observe inequities or gender stereotyping on the playing
field or in the physical education classroom, it is often best to openly
confront issues of prejudice such as sexism. (Research Report, Section
III)
- Involvement in physical activity, exercise and sport promotes
psychological well-being; the therapeutic use of physical activity and
exercise for improving the mental health of adolescent girls goes beyond
traditional treatment and mental health programs. (Research Report,
Section IV)
- Physical activity and exercise have been shown to be a mood enhancer
and an anxiety reducer, thereby acting as a natural, cost-effective
intervention for the mental health of adolescent girls. (Introduction;
Research Report, Sections II and IV)
View Full Article
Reprinted with the permission of the President's Council on Physical Fitness and Sports.