Preparing for College: Exercising Your Options: Tips for Student-Athletes

By — National Association for College Admission Counseling
Updated on Mar 13, 2009

You are an athlete. You look forward to working out, to pushing yourself, to competing against yourself and others. Perhaps you're a first-string quarterback, or a top gymnast or a star forward. Maybe you aren't a star, but you certainly give your competitors a run for their money. Or you may be happy to play just for the love of your sport.

Whatever your sport or skill level is, college offers you the opportunity to continue your participation and even to raise your skill to a higher level. From big-name varsity teams to campus intramural leagues, colleges have a variety of ways for student-athletes to hone their skills. To help you sort through the many options available to college-bound athletes, here are some things to consider when choosing a college.

The Fundamentals

"Choose the school, not the team," says Sarah McGinty, an independent educational consultant and supervisor of the Harvard Graduate School of Education teacher accreditation program.

It's easy to be dazzled by an exciting sports program or a great coach. But keep in mind that college is more than sports.

"The main factor in choosing a college should be academics," says Susan Hannon, guidance counselor at Rye Neck High School (NY). "Why academics? What if a student-athlete suffers an athletic career-ending injury or is unhappy with the team and quits? Will they still be happy at the school they chose or are they going to have to transfer to find this happiness?"

A good strategy for student-athletes, then, is to consider their sport as just one of the many characteristics to look for in a college.

Making the Team

One of the most important aspects of assessing your college athletic options is assessing your own skills and interests. It's fun to daydream about playing football for a Big 10 school or playing in the NCAA basketball finals, but you need to give your athletic abilities a cold, hard look.

"Athletes who overrate their ability may be set up for disappointment later on," says Hannon.

Talk to your coach about what NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic Association) division may fit your abilities and interests. You may also want to participate in a college showcase that "rates" student-athletes according to what different divisions require. The NCAA has three divisions:

  • Division 1 is the most competitive, has the highest profile and offers athletic scholarships.
  • Division 2 is the second tier, with an above-average level of competition, a somewhat lower profile and scholarship opportunities.
  • Division 3 is made up mostly of smaller colleges, which range from division powerhouses to no-cut teams. Athletes in this division are students first, athletes second; there are no athletic scholarships (but Division 3 schools still have financial aid and academic scholarships).

Admission and athletic experts generally agree that if you are Division 1 material, you'll know it fairly quickly. In Division 1, sports are a serious business, and recruitment efforts are extensive and nationwide. If you're not being recruited by Division 1 schools, you should probably turn your attention to Division 2 or 3 schools.

To find out if you could make it at Division 2 colleges, send the coaches at a few Division 2 schools your information, statistics and a videotape of you playing. (Make sure to indicate which player you are on the videotape!) If you find that Division 2 coaches are very enthusiastic about your skills and are willing to offer you athletic scholarships, you may want to send your tapes and information to a few Division 1 schools, just to explore all of your options.

Division 3 schools differ from the other two divisions in financial support and philosophy. This division does not have athletic scholarships, although student-athletes can still get financial aid and other types of scholarships. Many Division 3 colleges operate on more of a participatory model than do the other divisions. At Division 3 colleges, athletics is considered to be on the same level as other activities, and student-athletes are definitely students first.

Even if you have the skills to compete at a Division 1 level, you must decide if you really want such a high level of commitment to your sport.

"Some student-athletes just want to play; others want to play at the highest level they can," says Hannon.

Each division offers its own advantages and disadvantages. If you want to play sports primarily for fun, you may not want the sometimes all-consuming commitment of Division 1. But if you have a good shot at making it to the pros, Division 1 may be the best choice (remember, though, that very few players--even those in Division 1 college programs--advance to the professional level). If you are on the borderline between two divisions or between two colleges with differing levels of competitiveness in your sport, consider how much participation means to you: would you rather be in the starting lineup for four years in Division 3, or have a greater challenge but sit on the bench more often in Division 2?

"Go where you can compete as soon as possible, which means traveling with the team, improving as an athlete and gaining some success," advises Bruce J. Jones, counselor at Plymouth Middle School (MA) and experienced cross-country and track coach.

View Full Article
Add your own comment
DIY Worksheets
Make puzzles and printables that are educational, personal, and fun!
Matching Lists
Quickly create fun match-up worksheets using your own words.
Word Searches
Use your own word lists to create and print custom word searches.
Crossword Puzzles
Make custom crossword puzzles using your own words and clues.