Education.com

How to Approach Each Question Type on the AP U.S. History Exam (page 3)

based on 2 ratings

Reading and Interpreting Primary Source Documents

As a student of AP U.S. History, you will undoubtedly be spending a lot of time this year analyzing primary source documents. Your teacher will probably give you a number of them to read during the year; in addition, the document-based questions (DBQs) that are on every AP examination in May will ask you to read and interpret a number of primary sources and then to make a historical argument based upon them.

Historical documents, accounts, and books can be either primary or secondary sources. A secondary source is an account written after the fact. A chapter in your textbook is a secondary source, as is a biography, for example, of Franklin Roosevelt written in 2005. However, when historians write secondary source accounts, their research should include a thorough study of the available primary sources. A primary source is a document from the era or person in question. A primary source relating to George Washington might be a letter that George Washington wrote when he was at Valley Forge, an account on Washington written by someone who knew him personally, or a portrait of Washington that was done when he was alive. Primary sources relating to the 1950s might be a speech made by Senator Joseph McCarthy, a recording of the song “Hound Dog” by Elvis Presley, or an episode of the television show “The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.” (Note that primary source documents are not limited to written documents.) Secondary source accounts such as your textbook usually have excerpts from various primary source accounts scattered throughout the chapters.

Analyzing primary source documents allows you to study history as a historian does. When you are analyzing, for example, the actual text of a fi reside chat given by Franklin Roosevelt in 1933, you are the one doing the historical analysis; no other historian or author is doing the work for you. Types of primary source documents that you will be reading will include:

Published documents from a time period—These will include magazine articles, newspaper accounts, official government documents, posters, Supreme Court decisions, novels written during the era, and countless other sources.

Resources published after the fact—These will include letters and diaries written by historical (and non-historical) figures that were not originally meant for publication. These can be incredibly revealing; many politicians, for example, are much more honest in their diary entries than they are when they are giving speeches to the public. Oral histories are also very valuable and can be found at many local historical societies. A wonderful primary source would be the transcript (or audiotape) of a “common person” telling about the effect of the Great Depression on their family and community.

Visual documents—Paintings and photographs can provide incredibly revealing details about any time period you may be studying. Recently, the photographs of people waiting for help after Hurricane Katrina told more about the suffering in New Orleans than a thousand-word article could have. In 1945, photographs from recently liberated Nazi concentration camps shocked the world. Newsreel and television footage of historical events can also be invaluable.

Films—Movies from any era can provide a fascinating window into the values and beliefs of that period. By watching a film from, for example, the 1980s, you can get an idea of how people talked, what they wore, and what they believed in that era. A 1967 movie, “Bonnie and Clyde,” glorified the lives of Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow, two small-time gangsters who continually fl outed authority during the Great Depression. Although this film was about the 1930s, it perfectly reflected the disrespect for authority of many young people in the late 1960s.

Songs, recordings, etc.—Sources that one can listen to can also be valuable. As with fi lms, songs are very valuable windows into the culture and values of a time period, whether it is “Fight the Power” by Public Enemy or “Masters of War” by Bob Dylan. Listening to speeches given by historical figures can also be a valuable historical tool.

It should be remembered that virtually every single primary source document contains some amount of bias. Memoirs written by many historical figures are generally self-serving, and generally do not dwell on mistakes and problems from the writer’s past. It is virtually impossible to write about anything without bias; therefore, it is critical to consider this when evaluating primary sources. A source in which an observer discusses the impact that Theodore Roosevelt had on people when he met them would be influenced by preexisting judgments and opinions the author already had about Theodore Roosevelt. As a result, it is necessary to use a number of primary sources when evaluating a historical fi gure, event, or era.

Analyzing Primary Source Documents

There are many methods that historians and students can utilize when studying primary source documents. When looking at a document, try to find some information about its producer: what the relationship of the author was to the person/event being described; whether the producer had preexisting biases toward the subject of the document; and how far after the events being described was the document actually written. Another important question is the audience: the historian/student should identify the target group at which the document was aimed, and whether or not this might have influenced what was stated by the author. Students wanting more specifi c information on analyzing primary source documents can turn to numerous resources, including the Learning Page of the Library of Congress (http:// memory.loc.gov/ learn/lesson/psources/analyze/html) or an excellent analysis of the use of primary sources available from the Wisconsin Historical Society (www. wisconsinhistory .org/turningpoints/primarysources.asp). (

View Full Article

Add your own comment

Anonymous
Welcome!
Please
Not a Member? Join now!