Can Too Much Self-Esteem Be Bad for Your Child?
- Nurturing Self-Esteem in Your Child
- 4 Ways Parents Can Raise Their Kid's Self Esteem
- Building Self-Esteem in Preschool
- Building Self-Esteem in Children
- Dimensions of Self-Esteem
- Helping to Maintain the Self-Esteem of a Child Who is Wetting the Bed
Phrases like “good sharing!” and “great job on the slide!” echo across American playgrounds. Coaches pass out ribbons to every participant. Scholastic publishes a series called “I’m Special!” assuring readers that the ability to play with friends and sing songs makes them special indeed. We’ve been told that high self-esteem is the key to children’s happiness and success, and we’ve been praising and protecting them ever since. But has the self-esteem movement gone too far?
Many experts argue that instead of raising healthy high achievers, we’re may be raising a generation of narcissists. “Our old notions of self-esteem, like blood letting and alchemy, are passe, and parents need to send the concept to the trash heap of all things antiquated and useless,” says Aaron Cooper, Ph.D, co-author of I Just Want My Kids to be Happy: Why You Shouldn’t Say it, Why You Shouldn’t Think it, What You Should Embrace Instead.
While experts used to blame low self-esteem for everything from bad grades to criminal behavior, research has shown that inflated self-esteem is more often the culprit. An article called “Rethinking Self-Esteem” by Roy Baumeister, a Professor of Social Psychology at Florida State University, made a stir when he posited that criminals and drug abusers actually have higher self-esteem than the general population. Martin Seligman, Ph.D and Ervin Straub, Ph.D, found that the modern habit of constant praise was turning kids cynical and unmotivated. And esteemed child development expert T. Barry Brazelton, M.D. recently wrote in The New York Times that the phrase “self-esteem” had lost its meaning.
Parents just want their children to have a positive self-image. And while it’s easy to poke fun at the excesses of the self-esteem movement, it’s difficult to walk the fine line between instilling self-respect and self-centeredness. Here are some tips on finding the right balance.
- Save the praise for real accomplishments. Children recognize empty words, and when they go to college they’ll need internal motivation to thrive without constant feedback. “A steady diet of flimsy praise only turns us into praise addicts,” says Cooper.
- Challenge your kids in ways that force them to stretch and grow, but also leave room for success. If they’re never challenged, they’ll never feel accomplishment and pride. If the challenges seem insurmountable, they’ll give up.
- Let them fail sometimes. It’s hard for parents to watch their kids fall down, but resilience is a learned (and vital) trait. “Children suffer when we shield them, in the name of promoting self-esteem, from the way life works: that we don’t always win, that we’re not necessarily the best in everything we do,” says Cooper.
- Make it clear that while you have expectations for their behavior, you love and accept them unconditionally.
True self-esteem isn’t about a steady stream of compliments and applause; it develops when children know their limits and responsibilities, are given ample opportunities to challenge themselves, and feel secure that they’re loved even when they fail. Confident kids don’t expect the world to revolve around them; even a star is part of a constellation. And that’s something we can all feel good about.