Teen Writing Skills in a Tech World (page 2)
- The Ups and Downs of Teen Blogging
- Developing Early Writing Skills
- The Top 10 Tech Skills Your Teen Needs Now
- 8 Essential Writing Apps for Kids
- Developing Handwriting Skills
- The Joy of Writing
Early last month the results of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NEAP) were released, and they held relatively good news. Despite opinions to the contrary, our chat-enabled, Internet-savvy, IM-happy teens are continuing to master the “basic” writing skills they needed to coherently convey information (without acronyms or emoticons!). In fact, the average score on the writing component of the assessment has increased for both 8th and 12th graders since the last exam was given in 2002, indicating that more students are grasping the essentials of writing.
"Good writing means you can tell a story, provide information and persuade people with your words," says Mark Schneider, Commissioner of the National Center for Education Statistics. Schneider acknowledged that we still need to make progress, but that students are getting better at mastering the basics. In fact, not only did the average score increase by 3 points for 8th graders and 5 points for 12th graders, but approximately 85 percent of all students performed "at or above" the Basic level.
Students in 45 states and across two grade levels participated in the NAEP Writing Framework assessment, for which the questions and scoring rubrics are developed by the National Assessment Governing Board. Both 8th and 12th graders were assessed on their ability to use writing in three different ways: for narrative, informative and persuasive purposes. Students who take the exam are divided into three levels - Basic, Proficient and Advanced - based on their scores on a 300-point scale and the coherence and cohesiveness of their writing samples.
What exactly does this mean? Taking a closer look at the National Assessment Governing Board's Achievement Level descriptions sheds some light. Below are the requirements for 8th graders, as outlined in the Writing Framework and Specifications for the 2007 National Assessment of Educational Progress. For 12th graders, the ante is upped; mastering Basic skills is akin to the Proficient skills of an 8th grader, while Proficient is essentially the younger grade's Advanced level.
- Basic (8th grade)...students are aware of the audience they are expected to address, and should include supporting details in an organized way. The grammar, spelling, punctuation and capitalization in the work should be accurate enough to communicate to a reader, although there may be mistakes that get in the way of meaning.
- Proficient (8th grade)...writing should be organized, making use of techniques such as sequencing or a clearly marked beginning and ending, and it should make use of details and some elaboration to support and develop the main idea of the piece. Their writing should include precise language and some variety in sentence structure, and it may show analytical, evaluative, or creative thinking. The grammar, spelling, punctuation, and capitalization in the work should be accurate enough to communicate to a reader; there may be some errors, but these should not get in the way of meaning.
- Advanced (8th grade)...writing should show some analytical, evaluative, or creative thinking, and should demonstrate precise word choice and varied sentence structure. Their work should include details and elaboration that support and develop the main idea of the piece, and it may make use of strategies such as analogies, illustrations, examples, anecdotes, or figurative language to clarify a point. At the same time, the writing should show that these students can keep their work clearly and consistently organized. Writing by eighth-grade students performing at the Advanced level should contain few errors in grammar, spelling, punctuation, capitalization, and sentence structure.
At first glance, having nearly three-fourths of students acquire Basic writing skills seems like a coup, but some question whether that's good enough, when, in his own statement, Schneider commented, "Ultimately, the goal is to have all students performing at or above the Proficient level." Clearly that's not happening. Only one-third of all 8th graders and one-fourth of all 12th graders demonstrated Proficiency--a percentage that hasn't changed significantly since the last administration of the NAEP. There also continue to be significant gaps in scores between genders and socio-economic groups. On average, girls tend to score a full 20 points higher than boys, and students who qualify for free lunch have an average 25 points less than their non-eligible counterparts.
While it's encouraging to know that America's students are continuing to learn effective written communication skills, according to Kati Haycock, President of The Education Trust, the increases are encouraging, but not encouraging enough. In a press release, she noted, "In a world that gets smaller, more competitive and more diverse every day, Basic just doesn’t cut it. It doesn’t get kids where they need to go, and it doesn’t get our country where we need go."
In the end, though, students are showing improvement in an academic arena many fear is being overtaken by an electronic world. Proof that contradicts that fear is, in itself, encouraging.