edmutai
edmutai asks:
Q:
how do i handle my four and half years daughter she is so harsh and rude,i.e she says am not coming when u call her
In Topics: Discipline and behavior challenges
> 60 days ago

|

Expert

Boys Town National Hotline
Jan 24, 2012
Subscribe to Expert

What the Expert Says:

Parenting can be difficult on a good day and some days when our children push our buttons a little more it seems the day will never end.  

Our children often provide us with so many challenges that it is
difficult to decide which one to deal with first.  At 4 1/2 it sounds as
though your daughter is testing your limits to see how much you will
tolerate before you do something about it.
 
You mentioned that she talks back and behaves rudely.  We can only assume that it happens when she is told to do something or when her parent initiates some type of verbal communication.  Both of these behaviors are not
unusual but they are irritating and if not corrected will become
unbearable.  
 
We suggest teaching her social skills to start with.  To replace the
inappropriate behavior of talking back and behaving rudely, we suggest that you work with her on Following Instructions and Answering Appropriately.  There are a few simple steps to that skill;
1.) Look at the person who is talking to you.  2.) Say "okay".
3.) Do the task immediately.  4.) Check back when finished.  No where in
those steps does it allow for any words to be spoken besides "okay".  
 
We suggest first teaching these skills to your daughter when her basic needs, ie. nap, snack, bathroom breaks have been met. Let her know that you want to talk with her about something that isn't okay with how she answers you when being called or asked to do something.  You want to teach her how to do this correctly and you have something that you want her to do that will make things better for everyone.  Then describe the skill and the steps.  Give her a good "kid reason" for doing it that way. Then have her show you how she will use the skill, not just tell you, so a practice occurs right then and there.  It may sound something like this,
" Honey, you know how when we ask you to come to dinner or to do something and you yell back saying you are not coming?   Well we are going to try something new because that isn't okay anymore.  The next time you are asked or
told to do something, there is a specific way to respond.  First look at
whoever is talking to you or stop what you are doing and then answer okay. this is the only answer you should give.  Then get up immediately and
do the task in the best way possible and let us know when you are
finished and coming to the table.   If you can do it this way, then you can get back to doing what you want to do much quicker.  Let's try this, could you please show me how you will come to the dinner table. Make sure she follows each step just as you have described it to her.
Reinforce her when she does.  Be enthusiastic but sincere with your
praise.  Let her know that you will be practicing some more.  When you
do, ask her to do some fun things also, not just chores or coming to the table.  practice picking up toys, helping mom with laundry and such.
 
Use the same technique to teach other social skills that she is lacking
or that she is not demonstrating appropriately. Asking Permission, Accepting a Consequence, Listening, Accepting a NO Answer, Staying on Task and many many others can be taught and practiced to increase the likelihood that she will use them in the future.
 
Misbehaviors are opportunities for parents to teach skills.  If you can
adjust to that mind frame it will also reduce your frustration level and
have long lasting results and rewards.

Good luck,
Naina, counselor
Boys Town National Hotline
1-800-448-3000
Hotline@boystown.org

Did you find this answer useful?
1
yes
0
no

Additional Answers (2)

ab3304
ab3304 writes:
Children learn by example.  Beating your child is not a good example.  You are teaching your child to hit people.

Have you considered having a conversation with your child?  Did it ever occur to you that perhaps your child might be a person?  Do you listen to your child or do you simply tell your child what to do?  Do you treat her like a person or do you treat her like you treat your dog?

There are laws against torturing animals.  Maybe you should think about applying some of those laws to your child and not treat her like she's your pet to do with as you please.

My neighbor smacks his dog around.  It upsets him when his dog runs over to me.  I pet the dog kindly, scratch her behind the ears and treat her as if I like her because I like her.  The dog is always happy to see me.  The dog cringes when my neighbor puts his hand out.  He can't understand why the dog doesn't always listen to him and he has to yell at her and chase after her.  I never chase the dog.  The dog always runs to me.

Are you harsh and rude to your child?  Do you give your child a reason to come to you or do you give your child a reason to avoid you?  I see kids at the market, some are very well behaved, others are out of control.  The well behaved children ask their mother or father a question, the parent responds calmly with love.

The out of control kids grab things off shelves, sit down on the floor, throw tantrums, etc.  Their parents grab their hands, yank them around, drag them, scream at them, spank them and other immature behavior.  Where do you think the child gets it?

Which child do you think will grow up to be a bully, either verbal or physical.  Which child do you think will be a problem child in school and at home.  Which child do you think will hit other people and pick fights?  Here's a hint.  Children only know what they're taught.  What is your child learning from you?
> 60 days ago

Did you find this answer useful?
2
yes
0
no
littleredboat
littleredboat writes:
1.  What every she is doing or playing with must be taken away immediately.  So if she is playing with her dolls, take them away, if she is watching TV turn it off.

2. Every time she does not come you must go get her and have a talk with her  - everytime about the importance of listening and doing what mommy and daddy say. Then put her to stand in the corner until she apologies for not listening and says she wants to come out.

3.  The first time she asks to come out of the corner pretend you do not hear her, also the second time( you must be  in the room where she is being punished)
She will call your name again - then go to her and ask her how she felt when she called you and you did not answer .

But remember she must be punished everytime she talks back to you.  You can never be too tired or can't be  bothered.
> 60 days ago

Did you find this answer useful?
0
yes
0
no
Answer this question
Anonymous
Welcome!
Please sign in.
Not a Member? Join now!