lekemper asks:

Optimal class length for a second grader's attention span

My son attends a dedicated advanced placement school.  Socially he is on a par with kids his age.  Cognitively he is appropriately placed in 2nd APP which is doing 3rd and 4th grade curriculum.  He is thriving in this environment.

Many parents have been raising concerns about the sudden lack of morning snack this year and kids coming home with half eaten lunches like in previous years.  The emails have been flying.  I talked to my son about it.  He says he's not allowed to grab a snack out of his lunch at morning recess, then by the time it's lunchtime he's so far past hungry that he's not hungry anymore, and all he wants to do is socialize and get to after-lunch recess.  I have done some research and concluded the ultimate problem is that they go out to recess after lunch not before.  Many schools are switching due to overwhelming evidence that kids eat more and learn better when they play first.

The schedule currently is as follows:
9:10 school starts
10:30-10:40 morning recess
11:50-12:10 lunch followed by recess

I once heard adults have an optimal attention span of about 40min.  Supposedly this is why college classes are 45 - 50 min long.  It seems unreasonable to me, therefore, to make 7-8 year old kids sit in class for 80 min, 10 min break, then another 70 min, on no food.  My son eats breakfast at 7:30 in the morning because his bus comes at 8:00.  If he were to eat every 3 hours like he does at home, this would mean a morning snack around 10:30 and lunch around 1:30.  (Yep, I give him an afternoon snack when he gets home at 4:00 then we eat dinner around 7:00.)  Anyway, his school principal says she is constrained by the fact that her cook needs to be done serving no later than 12:20.

I think reversing recess / lunch times is the ideal solution to solve the blood sugar issues, but it begs the question about how long children can sit in a classroom.  So, how long can children that age sit and pay attention?
In Topics: My gifted child
> 60 days ago


Answers (1)

jgoff30344 writes:
Second grade teacher here...if I'm having read-aloud and the book is interesting,
my class can sit 10-15 minutes.  By the time the book is finished, I generally have several boys who are on their hands and knees lifting their bottoms of the floor!
Teaching a child this age requires the child's participation and interactive lessons.
So...I'm going to say 15 minutes.

> 60 days ago

Did you find this answer useful?
Answer this question


You are about to choose ${username}'s answer as the best answer.

Cancel | Continue

*You can change the best answer in the future if you think that you received a better answer

How likely are you to recommend Education.com to your friends and colleagues?

Not at all likely
Extremely likely