Anonymous
asks:
Q:
Should parents give their children herbal supplements for stress and other emotions?
I was perusing a parenting magazine this weekend and came across a featured promotion for an herbal supplement series for kids focused on 'emotional balance'. I've seen such herbal supplements for adults, and have even tried them (such as "Rescue Remedy"). While I didn't find them very effective physically (I wasn't able to stop crying, or stop anger shakes, or feel more calm), I have to admit that the act of taking something to 'calm down' did make me feel that at least I was trying something to feel better rather than just sink into further sadness or give completely into the emotional downward spiral.
However, with kids, I worry that this may not be the best approach. Are we doing more harm than good if we teach children to take a pill or 'medicine' when they feel stressed, angry or sad? I understand that medicine and pills are necessary for some medical and behavioral conditions, like depression and ADHD, but this product I saw advertised focuses on "restoring balance" for "happy, healthy kids". Shouldn't we instead teach children emotional intelligence and how to regain calm without taking pills or herbal supplements? What do you think?
In Topics:
My child's growth and development, Parenting / Our Family, Children and stress
However, with kids, I worry that this may not be the best approach. Are we doing more harm than good if we teach children to take a pill or 'medicine' when they feel stressed, angry or sad? I understand that medicine and pills are necessary for some medical and behavioral conditions, like depression and ADHD, but this product I saw advertised focuses on "restoring balance" for "happy, healthy kids". Shouldn't we instead teach children emotional intelligence and how to regain calm without taking pills or herbal supplements? What do you think?
> 60 days ago
What the Expert Says:
Resources:
Additional Answers (1)
Herbal supplements are not regulated by the FDA. Therefore, their safety and effectiveness, especially in children, cannot be guaranteed. Moreover, although natural, herbs work like pharmaceutical products. They may interact with medications and cause adverse or allergic reactions. Before trying any herbal products on children or even yourself, check with your health care provider to assure your safety.
Emotional problems in children and adults result from various problems. I see depression across lifespan in my clinical practice everyday. If you think that your child is sad most of the time, does not enjoy his or her usual activities, or does not want to spend time with friends, it is the time for an evaluation by your health care provider.
Emotional problems in children and adults result from various problems. I see depression across lifespan in my clinical practice everyday. If you think that your child is sad most of the time, does not enjoy his or her usual activities, or does not want to spend time with friends, it is the time for an evaluation by your health care provider.
Resources:
> 60 days ago
