Hi,
I think as parents we all live in fear of our kids engaging in behavior we know can (or will) be harmful. And it must be especially scary for you considering your family's history of addiction. I understand why you and your wife are considering severe punishments and I know you're just trying to give him a "wake up call" and keep him from continuing this behavior (smoking) or going further down the path of substance abuse.
But I think if you take away the trip, you'll push him away from you when really, what you want at this stage in his life, is to get closer to him. He sounds like a really together kid and he owned up to the cigarettes being his and to having tried them. Even if that's not the "whole truth" (i.e. if he smoked more of them himself than he said he did), it's still a lot more of the truth than many kids would have given.
I think a great start here would be a serious heart to heart talk. If you haven't already, maybe it's time to share some of your family's history and to tell him why you're taking this pack of cigarettes so seriously. Talk to him about some of the terrible consequences the family experienced as a result of drugs and alcohol. Explain that addiction really does "run in families" and that he's at much higher risk of becoming addicted to drugs or alcohol than someone who doesn't have addiction in their family - that other kids may be able to try drugs, or even use regularly for a while without losing control, but that he probably can't. Let him know why you don't smoke or drink and maybe share any negative experiences you had if you did those things in the past. Make sure he knows that he's not being "blamed" for the actions of his elders, just that he has an opportunity to learn from their troubles and mistakes.
That's where I think your research paper comes in (GREAT idea!). But maybe instead of sending him off to do it on his own, you could sit together to do the research. Believe it or not, Phillip Morris has a wonderful resource center (
http://www2.philipmorrisusa.com/en/prc/activities/activities.asp) to help parents and kids learn more about the harmful effects of smoking. Make sure he understands that nicotine is a drug - that it affects the brain and is addictive - just like harder drugs. It's especially important that he understands the negative impacts smoking can have on his body NOW as teens are prone to not thinking about, or caring about, life when they're "Old" (like in their 30s!). The threat of permanent bad breath today can be more frightening to a teen than the threat of lung cancer tomorrow. While your conversations should be broad and cover all substances, this project should probably focus just on smoking since, as far as you know, he hasn't tried other substances.
You also want to come out of that research process with some tools he can use to avoid peer pressure. Even at 16 it can still be pretty intense.
And maybe rather than a "research paper", maybe you could have him write a letter to himself as his "punishment". Ask him to write a few pages to himself about what he loves about his life, what he wants to accomplish in it, and how cigarettes could take away his ability to achieve those goals. You probably shouldn't make him show it to you but he may want to.
You should be really proud of the kid he is now - it has a lot, maybe everything, to do with you and your wife.
Good luck and please let us know how you're all doing.
Kat
Education.com Community Team