Education.com

Taking Care of Business: Discovering Personal Power (page 2)

Palo Alto Medical Foundation

‘Low-key Praise’ Is Best for Grades, Life

Simple encouragement and praise works far better as a stimulus to studying than elaborate rewards or punishment, according to a seminal study at Stanford University.

Students whose study habits are based on the reward/punishment pattern tend to perform poorly over the long term because they never learn to motivate themselves, the classic study found.

The study was conducted by Sanford Dornbusch, professor of human biology and sociology, as part of a three-year “Study of Stanford and the Schools,” based on information from more than 7,800 students and 3,500 parents in six Bay Area high schools (including Menlo Atherton and Los Altos highs).

Emotional upset is the worst possible reaction to poor grades. When parents are upset and the child is upset, we find an association with poor grades. Over time, the grades get worse.”

Likewise, parents who reward good grades with special gifts or vacations may be hurting their children’s future academic and career chances by substituting reward motivation for self-motivation. While children from single-parent or divorced families usually don’t do as well academically, a family’s behavior is more important than a family’s status or structure in determining school performance. 

Children of parents who are either “authoritarian” or “permissive” usually have lower grades than children of “authoritative” parents.

“Authoritarian” parents try to control their children through absolute standards, and emphasize values such as obedience and the preservation of order. “Permissive” parents make few demands, are highly tolerant and use avoid punishment. “Authoritative” parents use encouragement, firmness and open communication.

“The low-key use of (sincere) praise, encouragement, and offers of help is associated with higher grades.”

Premack’s Principle

The long-tested principle of personal “rewards” (as opposed to rewards from others) as a motivating factor for studying or taking care of personal business derives in large part from work done by David Premack, Ph.D., at the University of California, Santa Barbara, in the early 1960s. It has become known as the “Premack Principle” — it holds true today.

The idea essentially is that any activity you enjoy and spend a lot of time doing can be used as a reward for doing things you don’t enjoy as much and don’t spend enough time at.

Others have found that even hospitalized schizophrenics dramatically improve in self-care when things they enjoy — such as watching TV — are used as rewards for self care.

Self-rewards are equally effective.

View Full Article

Add your own comment

Ask a Question

Have questions about this article or topic? Ask
Ask
150 Characters allowed