The Shy Child

Why are some children more shy than others?

Some children are dispositionally shy: they are more likely than other children to react to new social situations with shy behavior. Even these children, however, may show shyness only in certain kinds of social encounters. Researchers have implicated both nurture and nature in these individual differences.

Some aspects of shyness are learned. Children's cultural background and family environment offer models of social behavior. Chinese children in day care have been found to be more socially reticent than Caucasian, and Swedish children report more social discomfort than Americans. Some parents, by labeling their children as shy, appear to encourage a self-fulfilling prophecy. Adults may cajole coyly shy children into social interaction, thus reinforcing shy behavior (Zimbardo and Radl, 1981).

There is growing evidence of a hereditary or temperamental basis for some variations of dispositional shyness. In fact, heredity plays a larger part in shyness than in any other personality trait (Daniels and Plomin, 1985). Adoption studies can predict shyness in adopted children from the biological mother's sociability. Extremely inhibited children show physiological differences from uninhibited children, including higher and more stable heart rates. From ages 2 to 5, the most inhibited children continue to show reticent behavior with new peers and adults (Reznick and others, 1986). Patterns of social passivity or inhibition are remarkably consistent in longitudinal studies of personality development.

Despite this evidence, most researchers emphasize that genetic influences probably account for only a small proportion of self-labeled shyness. Even hereditary predispositions can be modified. Adopted children do acquire some of their adoptive parents' social styles (Daniels and Plomin, 1985), and extremely inhibited toddlers sometimes become more socially comfortable through their parents' efforts (Reznick and others, 1986).

When is shyness a problem?

Shyness can be a normal, adaptive response to potentially overwhelming social experience. By being somewhat shy, children can withdraw temporarily and gain a sense of control. Generally, as children gain experience with unfamiliar people, shyness wanes. In the absence of other difficulties, shy children have not been found to be significantly at risk for psychiatric or behavior problems (Honig, 1987). In contrast, children who exhibit extreme shyness which is neither context-specific nor transient may be at some risk. Such children may lack social skills or have poor self-images (Sarafino, 1986). Shy children have been found to be less competent at initiating play with peers. School-age children who rate themselves as shy tend to like themselves less and to consider themselves less friendly and more passive than their non-shy peers (Zimbardo and Radl, 1981). Such factors negatively affect others' perceptions. Zimbardo reports that shy people are often judged by peers to be less friendly and likeable than non-shy people. For all these reasons, shy children may be neglected by peers, and have few chances to develop social skills. Children who continue to be excessively shy into adolescence and adulthood describe themselves as being more lonely, and having fewer close friends and relationships with members of the opposite sex, than their peers.

Strategies for helping a shy child

• Know and accept the whole child. Shyness is only one aspect of the child's personality. Being sensitive to the child's interests and feelings will allow you to build a relationship with the child and show that you respect the child. This can make the child more confident and less inhibited.
• Build self-esteem. Shy children may have negative self-images and may feel that they will not be accepted. Reinforce shy children for demonstrating skills and encourage their autonomy. Praise them often. "Children who feel good about themselves are not likely to be shy" (Sarafino, 1986, p. 191).
• Develop social skills. Reinforce shy children for social behavior, even if it is only parallel play. Honig (1987) recommends teaching children "social skill words" ("Can I play, too?") and role playing social entry techniques. Also, opportunities for play with young children in one-on-one situations may allow shy children to become more assertive (Furman, Rahe, and Hartup, 1979). Play with new groups of peers permits shy children to make a fresh start and achieve a higher peer status.
• Allow the shy child to warm up to new situations. Pushing a child into a situation which he or she sees as threatening is not likely to help the child build social skills. Help the child feel secure and provide interesting materials to lure him or her into social interactions (Honig, 1987).
• Remember that shyness is not all bad. Not every child needs or wants to be the focus of attention. Some qualities of shyness, such as modesty and reserve, are viewed as positive (Jones, Cheek, and Briggs, 1986). As long as a child does not seem excessively uncomfortable or neglected around others, drastic interventions are not necessary.

For More Information

Buss, Arnold. "A Theory of Shyness." In SHYNESS: PERSPECTIVES ON RESEARCH AND TREATMENT, edited by Warren Jones, Jonathan Cheek, and Stephen Briggs. New York: Plenum Press, 1986.

Daniels, Denise and Robert Plomin. "Origins of Individual Differences in Infant Shyness." DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY 21 (1985): 118-121.

Furman, Wyndol, Donald F. Rahe, and Willard W. Hartup. "Rehabilitation of Socially Withdrawn Preschool Children Through Mixed-Age and Same-Age Socialization." CHILD DEVELOPMENT 50 (1979): 915-922.

Honig, Alice S. "The Shy Child." YOUNG CHILDREN 42 (1987): 54-64.

Izard, Carroll E. and Marion C. Hyson. "Shyness As a Discrete Emotion." In SHYNESS: PERSPECTIVES ON RESEARCH AND TREATMENT, edited by Warren Jones, Jonathan Cheek, and Stephen Briggs. New York: Plenum Press, 1986.

Jones, Warren H., Jonathan M. Cheek, and Stephen R. Briggs, eds. SHYNESS: PERSPECTIVES ON RESEARCH AND TREATMENT. New York: Plenum Press, 1986.

Reznick, J.S., J. Kagan, N. Snidman, M. Gersten, K. Baak, and A. Rosenberg. "Inhibited and Uninhibited Children: A Follow-Up Study." CHILD DEVELOPMENT 57 (1986): 660-680.

Sarafino, Edward P. THE FEARS OF CHILDHOOD. New York: Human Science Press, Inc., 1986.

Zimbardo, Philip G. and S.L. Radl. THE SHY CHILD: A PARENT'S GUIDE TO PREVENTING AND OVERCOMING SHYNESS FROM INFANCY TO ADULTHOOD. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1981.